Video voyeurs have past in region; new state law toughens penalties for a crime

A initial offense, now a misconduct punishable by a year in a county jail and a $1,000 fine, would turn a transgression carrying a five-year jail judgment and $5,000 fine.

* * * * *

Currently, violators are usually charged with a third-degree transgression if convicted of dual before offenses. The new legislation would boost that to a second-degree felony, punishable by adult to 15 years in jail and $10,000 excellent after usually one before conviction.


See a formula »

View before polls »



A Bonita Springs male used his cellphone to “up-skirt,” holding videos underneath women’s skirts as he focussed over and simulated to tie his sneakers during Riverside Park.

An East Naples male is indicted of slicing holes in walls to sketch his roommates carrying sex and to watch a partner exposed in a bathroom.

And a son of a former Naples day caring core owners sits in a Collier County jail, indicted of touching immature girls and gnawing their exposed photos on his cellphone when they went to a day care’s bathroom.

Small and convenient, smartphones and tiny cameras concede users to simply snap cinema or videos. But in a deviant’s hands, that could finish in a rapist charge, video voyeurism. On a Internet, those photos and videos can go viral, as ESPN contributor Erin Andrews detected after an word executive followed her to 3 cities and shot videos by hotel peepholes that he posted on a Internet.

Prompted by an boost in crimes, Florida lawmakers are following a lead of states that have stiffened video voyeurism laws to keep adult with technology. Senate Bill 436, that upheld a Legislature this month, and a messenger House Bill 215, boost video voyeurism to a felony, enabling military to obtain hunt warrants to accumulate justification so prosecutors can build a case.

“It’s function everywhere,” pronounced Rep. Dana Young, R-Tampa, who sponsored a check during a propelling of Andrews’ father and after conference about dual sell students whose trainer and landlord commissioned cameras in fume and suit detectors in their bedroom and bathroom.

“Not a week goes by that we don’t review about one of these creeps being in a sauce room or during a tanning counter taping women,” Young said. “This is a initial step in safeguarding a adults from people regulating technology.”

The law now prohibits holding tip photos and videos, offered and distributing them, including on a Internet. It covers any place where a chairman has a “reasonable expectancy of privacy” while dressing, undressing or personally exposing a physique in bathrooms, changing rooms, sauce bedrooms or tanning booths.

It also bars up-skirting and identical offenses — regulating a device to personally view, promote or record underneath or by wardrobe though that person’s believe and consent.

The bills upheld by a Legislature supplement a “interior of a residential dwelling” and increases penalties.

A initial offense, now a misconduct punishable by a year in a county jail and a $1,000 fine, would turn a transgression carrying a five-year jail judgment and $5,000 fine.

Currently, violators are usually charged with a third-degree transgression if convicted of dual before offenses. The new legislation would boost that to a second-degree felony, punishable by adult to 15 years in jail and $10,000 excellent after usually one before conviction.

The bills are available Gov. Rick Scott’s signature and would turn law Jul 1.

With increasing direct for video voyeurism, there are hundreds of websites for up-skirting, down-blousing and peephole peeks, where Andrews’ photos remain. Her voyeur was condemned to 2½ years in an Illinois jail for widespread stalking.

“I’m being aggrieved each singular day for what he did,” Andrews pronounced during his sentencing dual years ago. “… This will never be over for me.”

At Boston University final month, 3 women were snapped immersion in dorms, according to news reports, that contend one tyro attempted to stomp on a iPhone, though a palm reached in and grabbed it. Last year, a 48-year-old Florida male was arrested, afterwards pleaded guilty and awaits sentencing, after videotaping dozens of women and 20 minors by a two-way counterpart and atmosphere opening hole during a feet of a tanning bed.

In Florida, a sell students didn’t know they were taped until dual group told them there were too many fume and suit detectors in a tiny apartment, pronounced their attorney, Mark Wright of Tampa.

“There was justification he was perplexing to request for a video voyeurism website,” Wright said. “We consider some good is going to come out of a law for people in a future.”

Until now, Southwest Florida violators have faced less-severe penalties.

Anthony J. Dinatale

Anthony J. Dinatale


David Bennett

David Bennett


Juan Nicolas Sanchez, 26, underwent a mental health evaluation, served a year of hearing and 3 months in jail after he was speckled by a shopper during an Immokalee supermarket as he focussed down, fixation his cellphone on his knee underneath her. Deputies found 7 shots with views underneath skirts though couldn’t brand other victims.

Armando Tiburcio Pineda, 30, of Bonita Springs, who shot up-skirt videos during a park, served 40 days in a Lee County jail.

David A. Bennett, 46, of East Naples, faces adult to a year in jail after a roommate in Nov found mechanism photos display his roommates carrying sex and a lady exposed in a bathroom. Deputies pronounced he’d cut holes in walls.

But Anthony DiNatale Jr., 32, not usually snapped exposed photos of dual girls going to a day caring core bathroom, he’s charged with touching them, nonetheless he still could be charged with video voyeurism if he heads to trial. He faces 15 years in jail — and life for an separate rape charge.

Experts determine changes are indispensable in a law.

“During a past 15 years, states have had to play legislative catch-up to residence a arise in video voyeurism due mostly to a accessibility of increasingly smaller dark cameras and smartphone record that allows anyone to play a purpose of voyeur,” pronounced profession Clay Calvert, a University of Florida highbrow who has complicated video voyeurism for some-more than a decade.

“Even when prosecutions targeting video voyeurs are successful, a problem lingers if a images prisoner already were uploaded to one of many intimately pithy voyeur websites,” Calvert said. “Once posted, a images will disseminate forever.”